In December 2008, in a concert at South Kitsap high school in Washington state, a group of students performed the Hallelujah Chorus from Handel’s The Messiah. Instead of singing, however, they displayed words printed on boards in time to a recording. The result was hilarious, and very popular. At this time, the video of that performance has had nearly 22 million views.

Four years later, the schools’ vocal music department put on the show again:

This video has had more than 13.5 million views.